Reinstating the 2020 Title IX Rule Amid Legal Shifts 

In January, a pivotal legal shift occurred when a Kentucky federal court vacated the nationwide Title IX 2024 rule. If your institution receives federal funding, this decision directly impacts how you manage compliance. Here’s why this legal action matters for you and how it connects to the President’s January 20, 2025 executive order on sex and gender. 

Under the vacated 2024 rule, training materials and policies had been broadened to cover more than just sexual harassment — expanding to include wider definitions of sex-based discrimination. However, the court’s decision has now rolled back those broader protections, and the Department of Education (DOE) has reverted to the 2020 rule. For education organizations, this means that you’ll need to adjust your approach: 

• Narrower definition: Only sexual harassment qualifies as a Title IX violation under the current framework. 

• Exclusion of broader protections: Protections no longer extend to issues of gender identity or sexual orientation under Title IX. 
  Optional training for institutions: The 2020 rule does not mandate Title IX training. 

While the rollback might seem to ease some compliance burdens, not aligning with the 2020 Title IX rule could expose your institution to legal risks and reputational harm.  

A closer look at the federal court decision 

The federal court decision marks a major turning point in Title IX history. The judge determined that the broader definitions in the 2024 rule went beyond what Congress originally intended. Simply put, the focus remains solely on sexual harassment. For HR professionals and school administrators, this is your cue to review your training materials and update them to meet the current legal standards. 

The connection between Trump’s executive order on gender and Title IX 

Before these changes, an executive order from the Trump administration had already narrowed the scope of Title IX training by focusing exclusively on sexual harassment and avoiding broader definitions that included gender identity and sexual orientation. This move was designed to simplify compliance and focus training on sexual harassment issues exclusively.  

Here’s what that means for you: 

• Focus on biological sex: Both the 2020 rule and the executive order emphasize that Title IX protections are based on biological sex, which means protections for gender identity and sexual orientation are excluded. 

• Policy consistency: The executive order set a clear direction for interpreting Title IX narrowly. The court’s decision reinforces this stance. 

• Impact on training and policies: Many educational institutions had adapted their policies to the broader 2024 rule. Now, with both legal and executive guidance pointing to a more restricted interpretation, it’s critical that you realign your training and internal policies accordingly. 

Why updating training is critical 

Even though the rollback might appear to reduce some compliance obligations, updating your training remains essential. Consider these points: 

• Stay aligned with current law: Ensuring that your training materials reflect the 2020 Title IX rule protects you from legal and compliance risks. 

• Avoid misinterpretation: If your staff has been trained under the broader guidelines of the 2024 rule, updating the training will help clear up any confusion about what constitutes a Title IX violation. 

• Maintain best practices: Even if Title IX training is no longer mandated, providing current and accurate training is a smart move — it equips your team with the knowledge to handle incidents effectively and maintain a safe, respectful environment. 

• Protect your institution’s reputation: Updated training minimizes legal risks and demonstrates your commitment to compliance and fairness. 

Next steps for educational organizations 

Staying ahead of these changes now can save you from future headaches. Here are some actionable steps to take: 

1. Review and audit: Go through your current Title IX training materials and pinpoint any references to the broader definitions from the 2024 rule. Make sure everything now aligns with the 2020 focus on sexual harassment. 

2. Update policies: Revise your internal policies to clearly state that Title IX protections now apply strictly based on biological sex. 

3. Communicate changes clearly: Inform your staff and administrators about these updates and explain the reasons behind them. Transparent communication can help prevent misunderstandings and ensure everyone is on the same page. 

4. Consult compliance experts: Work with specialists to verify that your policies and training meet the requirements of the 2020 Title IX framework. 

5. Refresh your training content: Clearly define what constitutes sexual harassment under Title IX and adjust any content that previously extended protections beyond what the law requires. 

6. Monitor ongoing developments: Stay updated with any future legal decisions or policy changes to keep your training materials current.